Silver Coins · American Silver Eagle
Sell your American Silver Eagles
The most popular silver bullion coin in the world — 1 oz .999 fine, from 1986 to today, bullion, proof and graded. Bring yours to any of our 4 Northern Virginia locations for a free appraisal and instant payout.
How we price it
How we price your American Silver Eagle
An American Silver Eagle holds one troy ounce of .999 fine silver, so its worth on any given day comes straight from the current silver spot price. Because silver costs a fraction of what gold does per ounce, the dollar amounts stay modest — yet the approach never changes: every figure is open, anchored to the live market, and talked through with you at the counter.
Each coin is authenticated and weighed while you watch. A standard bullion Eagle typically fetches 85–90% of silver spot, while proof, burnished, and slab-graded pieces — plus a handful of scarce dates — can be worth more, and any premium like that is built into the offer whenever the market allows.
You're paid by check on the same trip, before you head out the door, drawn on a local bank so you can cash it that day; nothing is mailed. Since the quote rides the live silver market, it stands the moment we give it and shifts only as spot moves.
What to bring and what to expect
Bring your Eagles in whatever form they are in — loose, stacked in tubes or a monster box, in capsules, or still sealed in Mint packaging — and include any grading slabs or paperwork if the coins are certified. You will also need a current government-issued photo ID; we ask every seller for one at all of our stores.
Chantilly, Annandale, and Manassas take walk-ins during store hours. Vienna / Tysons is currently by appointment, so call (703) 889-0532 before you go. Every visit gets a free, unhurried appraisal, and you take the number only if it works for you: say yes and a check is in your hand right then; say no and your Eagles go home with you, no fee either way.
The catalog
American Silver Eagles we buy
Search 187 American Silver Eagles by year, size or finish. Tap any coin to find your nearest store and bring it in for a free appraisal.
Showing 24 of 187
FAQ
American Silver Eagle: common questions
How much is an American Silver Eagle worth?
That comes down to the live silver spot price, since the coin is a full ounce of .999 fine silver. An everyday bullion Eagle typically brings 85–90% of its silver spot value, while proof, burnished, or graded examples can fetch more. Either way, you see the exact number before deciding.
Do you buy tubes and monster boxes of Silver Eagles?
Absolutely — a single coin, several full tubes, or a factory-sealed monster box are all welcome, and we value them against the live silver price. Bring whatever you have and we will count and appraise it at no charge.
Are proof or graded Silver Eagles worth more?
Often, yes. Proof and burnished issues, coins sealed in PCGS or NGC holders, and certain hard-to-find dates can trade above their metal value; we reflect that in the offer whenever the market rewards it.
Do I need the original box or certificate?
For ordinary bullion, no — the silver content is what we pay on. When a coin is proof or graded, keeping its packaging, paperwork, or sealed holder lets us confirm the grade and can lift what we pay.
Free appraisal
Ready to turn your valuables into cash?
Visit one of our four Northern Virginia stores for a free appraisal, or call ahead. You only sell if you love the offer.